Prompt: Which one of the following actions most clearly violates the principle stated?
Difficulty: šššš
How will the right answer fit in terms of support and conclusion?
Only the right answer will support the conclusion in the prompt that the principle has been violated.
Highlight the main conclusion in the passage, if there is one:
There is no conclusion in that mercifully short passage. Just a “principle”, which is always like a general rule.
[SUPPORT].
Map the wording of the answers to the wording of the passage:
(A) …she knew he did not think this; she did so merely to make him look ridiculous.
Does Ann “intentionally misrepresent” Bruce’s belief? For sure. Does she fit the exception in the passage about “the interest of that other person”? Nope, she was being mean on purpose. Violation! If you feel good about that, you can take the point and move on with worrying about the rest of the list.
(B) …he did so solely to keep this other person from bothering her.
It’s reasonable to say Claude is acting in Thelma’s interest, so he fits the exception in the passage. No violation.
(C) …Maria would not want him telling people this…
Does John “intentionally misrepresent” Maria’s beliefs? We don’t know. What she believes and what she “would not want him telling people” aren’t the same. This isn’t a violation.
(D) Harvey told Josephine that he thought…
Stop. The passage is about “another person’s beliefs”. Harvey is only misrepresenting his own belief here, so the principle isn’t even in effect. No violation.
(E) …she wanted people to know that George knew little about geography.
This doesn’t seem to be in George’s interest, and it doesn’t actually say what he believes anyway. So we don’t know if Wanda “intentionally misreprent”-ed his beliefs.
(A) is the correct answer.
Leave a comment